About the Product


Made with real Key lime juice, lime puree, and sweetened condensed milk in a buttery graham cracker crust - the way a true Key lime pie should be made - these flavorful tarts are the perfect summer dessert. Easy & convenient... just thaw, serve & enjoy!
  • Made with real Key lime juice
  • No artificial flavors or preservatives
  • Thaw & serve convenient
  • Perfect with whipped cream or on their own
  • Only available for a limited time

With their distinctive flavor and tantalizing bouquet, Key limes are a popular ingredient in a variety of desserts. In Omaha Steaks Key Lime Tarts, the tartness of the Key limes is perfectly balanced with sweetened condensed milk and the buttery graham cracker crust.

Made with real Key lime juice, these tarts contain no artificial flavors or preservatives. All you taste when you take a bite is true Key lime flavor. You'll forget you're in your kitchen or on your deck and imagine you're sitting in a restaurant overlooking the beach in Key West.

Top these Key Lime Tarts with fresh whipped cream and a slice of lime… or just eat them by themselves. Either way, they're the perfect dessert to finish off any delightful summer meal. But they're only available for a limited time… so make sure you enjoy some before they're gone!


Remove from wrapping. Gently push the bottom of the cup to release the pie and place on a serving plate, crust side down. Thaw in refrigerator for 45 minutes to 1 hour. Once thawed, serve within 48 hours.


*Express Shipping
Your package will arrive in 2-3 business days. Orders placed after 9:00 a.m. CT on Wednesday will arrive the following week.
*Rush Shipping
Order by 9:00 a.m. CT on weekdays and your package will arrive in the afternoon on the next business day. Rush Shipping is available Monday - Friday for delivery Tuesday - Saturday.
*Saturday Rush Shipping
Order by 9:00 a.m. CT on Friday's and your package will arrive in the afternoon on Saturday. Saturday Rush Shipping is available Thursday 9:00 a.m. CT - Friday 9:00 a.m. CT for Saturday delivery. Offer does not include surcharges for deliveries to Alaska, Hawaii, Canada, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. Some destinations may not qualify for Express and Rush shipping, please confirm your delivery date in the checkout. Gift Baskets and Wine are not included for Express, Rush, or Saturday shipping. This offer cannot be combined with any other offer and is not valid on pending or prior purchases.


4.53 / 5 stars

5 stars

Just looking at them and you can see the taste but eating them is a hole another experience of joy.
Herbert R.

5 stars

Everyone who has had these loved them.
Carl W.

5 stars

Always an excellent choice for dessert.
Thomas M.

1 stars

The reason I marked 1 star, is because when I received the shipment. Everything was warm, so I ended up tossing everything. I never get to try them. Maybe someday.
Barbara S.
Response from Omaha Steaks:
We're sorry to hear about your past experience with our product. If this issue has not been resolved, please feel free to contact us so we can assist you.

5 stars

Well if this helps my freezer has a section with boxes of these, that is how much we love them, as an ex Floridian I know good key lime, this is it!!
Maryoconnor -.

5 stars

These are excellent.
Gail C.

4 stars

Very good taste, too small.
John K.

5 stars

Taste amazing
Amanda G.

5 stars

Great key lime!
Mary K.

5 stars

They are wonderful.
Marilyn K.

5 stars

These tarts are oh so good.
Jane G.

5 stars

Delicious and can be an elegant dessert
Sandra A.

5 stars

Good to eat!
Carl V.

3 stars

Our very favorite!
Linda B.

5 stars

Omaha Steak's Key Lime Tarts are a dream. Cool, refreshing key lime. Not to tart, not to sweet. The perfect finish to a delicious meal.
Lauretta R.

5 stars

Love these tarts!! Quick to thaw.
-ugust P.

Key Lime Tarts

4 (4.65 oz.) tarts
Sign In
Forgot your email?
Forgot your password?
google icon
facebook icon
Are you new here?
Get the complete Omaha Steaks experience by creating an account.
Looking for something else?
Order Status
Steaklover Rewards
Find a Store
Welcome Back{{globalVars.sessionUserInfo.firstName ? ', ' + globalVars.sessionUserInfo.firstName : ''}}!
checkmark icon
Sign in Successful!
Create Your Account
Already have an account? Sign in
  • Shipping icon
    Keep Track of Orders
    Find the status of your orders and signup for alerts.
  • Gifting icon
    Better Gifting
    Never miss giving the perfect birthday gift again.
  • Gifting icon
    Faster Shopping
    Favorites make it quick and easy to reorder.
    By checking "Join Steaklover Rewards" you agree to enroll in the Steaklover Rewards loyalty program and to the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and CA/CO Financial Incentive Notice.
    By creating an account you agree to the Omaha Steaks terms of use and privacy policy. As a member you will receive the latest news, updates, and promotions from Omaha Steaks. You may update your contact preferences at any time.
    google icon
    facebook icon
    {{onboardingForm.activeStep}} of 3
    Get the complete
    Omaha Steaks
    I usually shop for:
    Return to My Account anytime to update your information, manage favorites, leave reviews and check your order status!
    Share your birthday for exclusive offers and special birthday surprises from Omaha Steaks!
    Provide your phone number for a better experience:
    • Even easier login and password reset
    • Faster, more accurate order updates
    • Exclusive Omaha Steaks deals
    Welcome {{globalVars.sessionUserInfo.firstName ? (', ' + globalVars.sessionUserInfo.firstName) : ''}}
    checkmark icon
    Sign in Successful!